What if I told you that Islamic law influences how billions of dollars are invested in American companies? Would you believe me? Well, this is written directly into the governing documents and marketing materials of a growing category of investment funds that control billions of dollars.5, 10
I began examining faith-based funds for competitive reasons. Morningstar counts 853 faith-based funds worldwide. Six hundred and fifty of them are Sharia-compliant. When it surveyed that universe, the largest single fund it found was not Christian or Catholic but Sharia-compliant: Amana Growth.
Amana is not an outlier. Three of America’s ten largest faith-based ETFs follow Sharia law, together holding about half the assets in that group.3 About $13 billion is invested this way in the United States. Globally, Islamic funds hold more than $375 billion.
This arrived through licensing agreements. Religious rules entered American markets because some index companies found it profitable to sell them.
S&P Global is not an Islamic institution. It writes and licenses a rulebook built to Islamic standards. In my view they weren’t converted. They were rented.
Muslim investors are entitled to products matching their beliefs. They also deserve clear explanations from the companies charging them.
Some major institutions profit from conventional capital markets while selling products built around religious restrictions on those markets’ essential mechanisms.
Sharia finance prohibits interest and restricts gambling-like speculation. Ordinary equity ownership is permissible. The tension is specific: how completely can a portfolio avoid interest when its companies operate inside an economy financed by it?
The industry’s answer: separation is often incomplete.
Saturna Capital, which manages Amana, acknowledges that avoiding prohibited income entirely is not always possible. Its guidelines generally exclude companies whose interest revenue exceeds 5% of total revenue, while requiring purification of prohibited income that remains.
The standard permits limited exposure rather than demanding complete avoidance.
Saturna even supplies purification calculators. For the fiscal year ended May 31, 2026, Amana Growth’s investor shares had a published purification factor of $0.005795 per share. Someone holding 1,000 shares would calculate approximately $5.80 to donate. Saturna says it does not deduct these amounts from investors’ accounts.
The amount may be small. The acknowledgment matters: screening measures and manages exposure, then asks investors to dispose of resulting income.
That may be an accepted accommodation. But investors should understand whether they are buying complete avoidance or a portfolio governed by thresholds, exceptions and subsequent purification.
Now consider the sellers.
S&P Global, which builds and licenses the stock indexes that funds are built to track, maintains Shariah benchmarks screening business activities and financial characteristics, including leverage and interest-earning assets. Its index business earns licensing revenue. Meanwhile, S&P Global Ratings earns fees assessing bonds, notes and loans.
In 2025, Ratings generated $4.72 billion and Indices generated $1.85 billion. These are division-wide figures, not Shariah-specific revenue.
In my opinion, Wall Street does not pass the screens it sells.8, 9 S&P’s own Shariah methodology removes three categories from the index: Aerospace & Defense, Financial Exchanges & Data, and Transaction & Payment Processing Services. GICS, which defines those categories, places ratings agencies and providers of financial decision-support products inside Financial Exchanges & Data. That is S&P Global’s own business. The firm that writes the screen sits in a category the screen removes.
The money runs the other way. Investors cannot own S&P Global through the fund, but fund expenses support licensing payments to it. They cannot own the stock exchange, but trading generates exchange fees.
The screen forbids the investment and permits the invoice.
BlackRock presents a similar tension. Through iShares, it offers Islamic equity funds. Until 2026, purification at its iShares MSCI USA Islamic UCITS ETF was the investor’s responsibility. The fund took the job over, donates the money to charities it picks, and stopped publishing the figures.
These European-domiciled products are not registered for sale to United States residents. Yet in my view the underlying business model is familiar: BlackRock earns fees managing conventional interest-bearing investments while collecting fees packaging products for investors seeking to avoid them.
The obvious defense is that managers serve clients with different preferences. True. But that clarifies what investors buy: a commercial screening service with defined limits, rather than a corporate commitment to the advertised principles.
The question is whether customers understand that the institutions selling religious compliance can profit from activities those same products exclude from their investment portfolios.
Explain those limits plainly. How much interest-related exposure is permitted? Who calculates prohibited income? Who performs purification? Does marketing communicate these compromises as clearly as technical documents?
A compliance label should begin that explanation, not replace it.
There is often a cultural double standard. Islamic portfolios are marketed as inclusive, ethical and values driven. Conservative Christians seeking funds that avoid abortion providers, pornography or corporations hostile to religious liberty are often accused of bringing politics into investing.
Both groups deserve consistent treatment. Neither should have to accept opaque standards because a familiar financial brand appears on the prospectus.
Muslim investors deserve products respecting their convictions and disclosures respecting their intelligence. S&P, BlackRock and other sellers should be judged on both.
Wall Street earns money from interest-based finance and the demand to avoid it. Investors deserve to understand the arrangement, including its compromises and costs.
In my view, they weren’t converted. They were rented. Ask them what the rent was.
Questions investors are asking
What is Sharia-compliant investing?
Sharia-compliant investing applies Islamic law to portfolio selection. It prohibits interest and restricts gambling-like speculation, while ordinary equity ownership is permitted. Funds apply screens that test a company’s business activities and financial characteristics, including leverage and interest-earning assets. Index providers write those rulebooks and license them to asset managers. About $13 billion is invested this way in the United States, and Islamic funds hold more than $375 billion globally.
Do Sharia-compliant funds avoid interest completely?
Often not. Saturna Capital, which manages Amana, acknowledges that avoiding prohibited income entirely is not always possible. Its guidelines generally exclude companies whose interest revenue exceeds 5% of total revenue, and ask investors to purify the prohibited income that remains. For the fiscal year ended May 31, 2026, Amana Growth’s investor shares carried a published purification factor of $0.005795 per share. The standard permits limited exposure rather than demanding complete avoidance.
Why do index providers offer Sharia screens?
Licensing revenue. Religious rules entered American markets because some index companies found it profitable to sell them. S&P Global maintains Shariah benchmarks that screen business activities and financial characteristics, and its index business earns licensing fees. The same company’s ratings business earns fees assessing bonds, notes and loans. S&P Global is not an Islamic institution. It writes and licenses a rulebook built to Islamic standards. In my view they weren’t converted. They were rented.
What should investors ask a fund that advertises religious or values-based compliance?
Four things. How much exposure to the prohibited activity is permitted? Who calculates prohibited income, and who performs purification? Does the marketing communicate these compromises as plainly as the technical documents do? And does the firm selling the screen profit from the activities the screen excludes? A compliance label should begin that explanation, not replace it. The same questions apply whatever belief a fund is built on.
Sources
1. Morningstar, “Faith-Based Investing: Global Landscape,” July 2026, page 2 — a universe of 853 active faith-based funds as of 30 April 2026, of which 650 are Shariah, 114 non-denominational Christian, 87 Catholic and one Jewish. Report: https://assets.contentstack.io/v3/assets/blt9415ea4cc4157833/blt4aa26b2b231b84fe/Faith-based-investing-2026.pdf (the landing page at https://www.morningstar.com/en-gb/business/insights/research/faith-based-investing states 850+ funds and $169 billion but does not give the breakdown by tradition).
2. Morningstar, “A Matter of Faith,” Norton and Saldanha — largest faith-based fund is Amana Growth. https://www.morningstar.com/sustainable-investing/matter-faith
3. Faith-based ETF assets, top ten: SP Funds https://www.sp-funds.com/spus/ ; Global X https://www.globalxetfs.com/funds/cath/ ; Pensions & Investments https://etf.pionline.com/fund/HLAL
4. ICD-LSEG Islamic Finance Development Report 2026, page 46 — total Islamic funds AuM US$375 billion across 2,696 funds with 22% year-on-year growth in 2025; the chart “Top countries by Islamic funds AuM (US$ billion, 2025)” gives the United States at 13. https://www.lseg.com/content/dam/data-analytics/en_us/documents/reports/lseg-islamic-finance-development-indicator-2026.pdf
5. Saturna Capital, “Halal Investing” — the five percent rule. https://www.saturna.com/funds/halal-investing
6. Saturna Capital, 2026 Purification Calculator — Amana Growth investor shares $0.005795 for the fiscal year ended 31 May 2026; amounts not deducted from accounts. https://www.saturna.com/products/tools
7. Saturna Capital, Amana Growth Fund factsheet, 30 September 2026. https://www.saturna.com/sites/saturna.com/files/files/AMAGX-AMIGX-FactSheet.pdf
8. S&P Dow Jones Indices, S&P Shariah Indices Methodology, October 2026, page 9 — excluded GICS sub-industries. https://www.spglobal.com/spdji/en/documents/methodologies/methodology-sp-shariah-indices.pdf
9. MSCI, Global Industry Classification Standard (GICS) Methodology, August 2024, page 45 — Financial Exchanges & Data includes ratings agencies. https://www.msci.com/indexes/documents/methodology/1_MSCI_Global_Industry_Classification_Standard_GICS_Methodology_20240801.pdf
10. SP Funds prospectus, 30 March 2026, page 2 — index exclusions. https://www.sp-funds.com/wp-content/uploads/spfunds-PRO_2026-06-05.pdf
11. S&P Global fourth quarter and full-year 2025 results, 10 February 2026 — Ratings $4,724 million, Indices $1,850 million. https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/64040/000006404026000007/a4q2025earningsrelease.htm
12. iShares II plc, shareholder letter to holders of the iShares MSCI USA Islamic UCITS ETF (ISIN IE00B296QM64), 17 October 2025 — purification moved inside the fund from 1 January 2026; impure dividends donated to charities selected by the manager; purification data no longer published. BlackRock serves this letter only to non-US visitors, so the link returns an error page from a United States browser: https://www.blackrock.com/lu/intermediaries/literature/shareholder-letters/ishares-ii-plc-shareholder-letters-isisusttl-en-17-oct-25.pdf — the same change is reported, and that report is reachable from the United States, at https://www.investing.com/news/company-news/islamic-fund-to-adopt-internal-dividend-purification-model-93CH-4295116
13. iShares MSCI USA Islamic UCITS ETF factsheet — Irish domicile; not aimed at United States residents. https://www.ishares.com/gls-download/literature/fact-sheet/isus-ishares-msci-usa-islamic-ucits-etf-fund-fact-sheet-en-gb.pdf
14. MSCI Islamic Index Series Methodology, October 2024, section 2.3 Dividend Purification, page 7. https://www.msci.com/indexes/documents/methodology/2_MSCI_Islamic_Index_Series_Methodology_20241030.pdf
Bill Flaig is the CEO & Co-Founder of the American Conservative Values ETF (NYSE: ACVF) with over $150M in AUM (Assets Under Management) as of 11/4/26. Learn more at www.investconservative.com
The views expressed are those of the authors as of 11/4/26 and are subject to change without notice. These opinions are not intended to be a forecast of future events, a guarantee of results, or investment advice.